Rscript -e does not accept newlines under Linux?

On 16/09/2018 4:53 AM, Voeten, C.C. wrote:

Hello,

I have found what I believe to be a bug in the Linux version of the 
Rscript binary.
Under Windows (official 64-bit 3.5.1 R distribution running on an 
up-to-date Win10), I can do the following (e.g. under powershell):

PS H:\Users\Cesko> Rscript -e 'ls()

ls()'

character(0)
character(0)

which works as I expect: I am running Rscript with two arguments, 
namely (1) '-e', and (2) two lines of code to be run, and it indeed 
executes those two lines of code.

This fails when attempted on a Linux build (amd64, compiled from the 
official 3.5.1 sources, but also reproducible with today's r-devel 
snapshot):

$ Rscript -e 'ls()
ls()'
ARGUMENT 'ls()' __ignored__

character(0)

This behavior is not what I expected. Have I found a bug, or am I 
simply using it wrong?

I would not assume that shell behaviour in Windows and Unix would 
always be the same.? A better comparison would be to list some other 
command on the same system that behaves differently.? For example, on 
MacOS I see

$ echo 'ls()

ls()'

ls()
ls()


which suggests that what you wrote should be legal, but the form of 
that command is different: there's no equivalent of "-e". Maybe 
someone else who knows Unix shell behaviour better can comment on 
whether they'd expect your Rscript command to work.

By the way, if you just want multiple commands to execute, you can 
separate them by semi-colons, and that does work:

$ Rscript -e 'ls(); ls()'
character(0)
character(0)

And I see this, which may explain the original problem:

$ Rscript -e 'commandArgs(); ls()'
[1] "/Library/Frameworks/R.framework/Resources/bin/exec/R"
[2] "--slave"
[3] "--no-restore"
[4] "-e"
[5] "commandArgs();~+~ls()"
character(0)

Notice that argument 5 includes both commands, whereas with the 
newline they are separated:

$ Rscript -e 'commandArgs()

ls()'

ARGUMENT 'ls()' __ignored__

[1] "/Library/Frameworks/R.framework/Resources/bin/exec/R"
[2] "--slave"
[3] "--no-restore"
[4] "-e"
[5] "commandArgs()"
[6] "ls()"

And finally, this also works:

Rscript -e 'ls()
-e
ls()'


Duncan Murdoch