[External] Re: should base R have a piping operator ?

On 7 Oct 2019, at 17:04, Tierney, Luke <luke-tierney at uiowa.edu> wrote:

 Think about what happens if an
argument in a pipe stage contains a pipe. (Not completely
unreasonable, e.g. for a left_join).

It should work exactly as it does in a local environment.

```
`%foo%` <- function(x, y) {
 env <- parent.frame()

 # Use `:=` to avoid partial matching on .env/.frame
 rlang::scoped_bindings(. := x, .env = env)

 eval(substitute(y), env)
}

"A" %foo% {
 print(.)
 "B" %foo% print(.)
 print(.)
}
#> [1] "A"
#> [1] "B"
#> [1] "A"

print(.)
#> Error in print(.) : object '.' not found

```

The advantage is that side effects (such as assigning variables or calling
`return()`) will occur in the expected environment.

You get the assignment behavior with the nested call approach. (Not
that doing this is necessarily a good idea).

I don't see it causing
problems except in artificial cases. Am I missing something?

Here is a stylized example:

f <- function(x, y) {
     assign("xx", x, parent.frame())
     on.exit(rm(xx, envir = parent.frame()))
     y
     get("xx") + 1
}

## This is fine:

f(1, 2) 

[1] 2

## This is not:

f(1, f(1, 2))

Error in get("xx") : object 'xx' not found

If you play these games whether you get the result you want, or an
obvious error, or just the wrong answer depends on argument evaluation
order and the like. You really don't want to go there. Not to mention
that you would be telling users they are not allowed to use '.' as a
variable name for their own purposes or you would be polluting their
environment with some other artificial symbol that they would see in
debugging. Just don't.

Anything going in base needs to worry even about artificial cases.
Yes, there are things in base that don't meet that standard. No, that
is not a reason to add more.

I agree that restraining the pipe to a single placeholder (to avoid
double evaluation) would be a good design too.

I can't access https://gitlab.com/luke-tierney/pipes, it appears to be 404.

Should be able to get there now. Needed to change the visibility ---
still learning my way around gitlab.

Best,

luke

Best,
Lionel

Luke Tierney
Ralph E. Wareham Professor of Mathematical Sciences
University of Iowa                  Phone:             319-335-3386
Department of Statistics and        Fax:               319-335-3017
    Actuarial Science
241 Schaeffer Hall                  email:   luke-tierney at uiowa.edu
Iowa City, IA 52242                 WWW:  http://www.stat.uiowa.edu