bug in summary.aovlist() with split= and (PR#13579)

-------62a8e378fd5c9332aae960888fd28459
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit

# R for Windows will not send your bug report automatically.
# Please copy the bug report (after finishing it) to
# your favorite email program and send it to
#
#       r-bugs at r-project.org
#

######################################################


summary.aovlist() with split= and expand.split=TRUE
gives two different types of nonsensical results for a:b
in the Within stratum in the two different expansions of tmp3.aov.

S-Plus gives appropriate results and I attach them for comparison.
There are three attached files.
 split.r   source
 split.rt  R transcript showing nonsense results
 split.st  S-Plus transcript showing appropriate results

Rich


--please do not edit the information below--

Version:
 platform = i386-pc-mingw32
 arch = i386
 os = mingw32
 system = i386, mingw32
 status = 
 major = 2
 minor = 8.1
 year = 2008
 month = 12
 day = 22
 svn rev = 47281
 language = R
 version.string = R version 2.8.1 (2008-12-22)

Windows XP (build 2600) Service Pack 3

Locale:
LC_COLLATE=English_United States.1252;LC_CTYPE=English_United 
States.1252;LC_MONETARY=English_United States.1252;LC_NUMERIC=C;LC_TIME=English_United States.1252

Search Path:
 .GlobalEnv, package:RcmdrPlugin.HH, package:Rcmdr, package:car, package:tcltk, package:fortunes, 
package:VGAM, package:stats4, package:splines, package:HH, package:leaps, package:multcomp, 
package:mvtnorm, package:grid, package:lattice, package:stats, package:graphics, package:datasets, 
package:grDevices, package:rcom, package:rscproxy, package:utils, package:methods, RExcelEnv, 
RcmdrEnv, Autoloads, package:base

-------62a8e378fd5c9332aae960888fd28459
Content-Type: text/plain;
	name="split.r"
Content-Disposition: inline;
	filename="split.r"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable

tmp <- data.frame(y=3Drnorm(48),
                  a=3Drep(letters[1:3]=
, 16),
                  b=3Drep(rep(LETTERS[1:4], each=3D3),4),
     =
             block=3Drep(LETTERS[5:6], each=3D24)
                  )
=

tmp.aov <- aov(y ~ a*b, data=3Dtmp)
summary(tmp.aov,
        split=3D=
list(a=3Dlist(t=3D1,u=3D2), b=3Dlist(v=3D1,w=3D2,x=3D3)),
        expan=
d.split=3DTRUE)

tmp2.aov <- aov(y ~ Error(block) + a*b, data=3Dtmp)
=
summary(tmp2.aov,
        split=3Dlist(a=3Dlist(t=3D1,u=3D2), b=3Dlist(=
v=3D1,w=3D2,x=3D3)),
        expand.split=3DTRUE)
summary(tmp2.aov,
 =
       split=3Dlist(a=3Dlist(t=3D1,u=3D2)),
        expand.split=3DTRUE=
)

tmp3.aov <- aov(y ~ Error(block/a) + a*b, data=3Dtmp)
summary(tmp3=
.aov,
        split=3Dlist(a=3Dlist(t=3D1,u=3D2), b=3Dlist(v=3D1,w=3D2,=
x=3D3)),
        expand.split=3DTRUE)
summary(tmp3.aov,
        split=
=3Dlist(a=3Dlist(t=3D1,u=3D2)),
        expand.split=3DTRUE)

-------62a8e378fd5c9332aae960888fd28459
Content-Type: text/plain;
	name="split.rt"
Content-Disposition: inline;
	filename="split.rt"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable

tmp <- data.frame(y=3Drnorm(48),

+                   a=3Drep(letters[=
1:3], 16),
+                   b=3Drep(rep(LETTERS[1:4], each=3D3),4),
+                   block=3Drep(LETTERS[5:6], each=3D24)
+             =
      )

=

tmp.aov <- aov(y ~ a*b, data=3Dtmp)
summary(tmp.aov,

+         spl=
it=3Dlist(a=3Dlist(t=3D1,u=3D2), b=3Dlist(v=3D1,w=3D2,x=3D3)),
+       =
  expand.split=3DTRUE)
            Df Sum Sq Mean Sq F value Pr(>F)
a =
           2  2.060   1.030  1.0528 0.3595
  a: t       1  1.411   1.41=
1  1.4416 0.2377
  a: u       1  0.650   0.650  0.6639 0.4205
b       =
     3  0.839   0.280  0.2859 0.8353
  b: v       1  0.264   0.264  0.2=
702 0.6063
  b: w       1  0.001   0.001  0.0013 0.9711
  b: x       1=
  0.573   0.573  0.5860 0.4489
a:b          6  2.300   0.383  0.3918 0.=
8794
  a:b: t.v   1  0.556   0.556  0.5685 0.4558
  a:b: u.v   1  0.99=
8   0.998  1.0203 0.3192
  a:b: t.w   1  0.171   0.171  0.1747 0.6785
=
  a:b: u.w   1  0.092   0.092  0.0942 0.7607
  a:b: t.x   1  0.361   0.=
361  0.3685 0.5476
  a:b: u.x   1  0.122   0.122  0.1246 0.7261
Residu=
als   36 35.226   0.978               =

=

tmp2.aov <- aov(y ~ Error(block) + a*b, data=3Dtmp)
summary(tmp2.ao=

v,
+         split=3Dlist(a=3Dlist(t=3D1,u=3D2), b=3Dlist(v=3D1,w=3D2,x=
=3D3)),
+         expand.split=3DTRUE)

Error: block
          Df  S=
um Sq Mean Sq F value Pr(>F)
Residuals  1 0.57849 0.57849              =
 =


Error: Within
           Df Sum Sq Mean Sq F value Pr(>F)
a         =
  2  2.060   1.030  1.0406 0.3639
  a: t      1  1.411   1.411  1.4250 =
0.2406
  a: u      1  0.650   0.650  0.6563 0.4234
b           3  0.83=
9   0.280  0.2826 0.8376
  b: v      1  0.264   0.264  0.2671 0.6085
 =
 b: w      1  0.001   0.001  0.0013 0.9713
  b: x      1  0.573   0.573=
  0.5793 0.4517
a:b         6  2.300   0.383  0.3873 0.8822
  a:b: t.v=
  1  0.556   0.556  0.5619 0.4585
  a:b: u.v  1  0.998   0.998  1.0085 =
0.3222
  a:b: t.w  1  0.171   0.171  0.1727 0.6803
  a:b: u.w  1  0.09=
2   0.092  0.0931 0.7621
  a:b: t.x  1  0.361   0.361  0.3642 0.5500
 =
 a:b: u.x  1  0.122   0.122  0.1232 0.7277
Residuals  35 34.647   0.990=
               =

summary(tmp2.aov,

+         split=3Dlist(a=3Dlist(t=3D1,u=3D2)),
+  =
       expand.split=3DTRUE)

Error: block
          Df  Sum Sq Mean S=
q F value Pr(>F)
Residuals  1 0.57849 0.57849               =


Error: Within
          Df Sum Sq Mean Sq F value Pr(>F)
a          =
2  2.060   1.030  1.0406 0.3639
  a: t     1  1.411   1.411  1.4250 0.2=
406
  a: u     1  0.650   0.650  0.6563 0.4234
b          3  0.839   0=
.280  0.2826 0.8376
a:b        6  2.300   0.383  0.3873 0.8822
  a:b: =
t   3  1.088   0.363  0.3663 0.7777
  a:b: u   3  1.212   0.404  0.4082=
 0.7480
Residuals 35 34.647   0.990               =

=

tmp3.aov <- aov(y ~ Error(block/a) + a*b, data=3Dtmp)
summary(tmp3.=

aov,
+         split=3Dlist(a=3Dlist(t=3D1,u=3D2), b=3Dlist(v=3D1,w=3D2=
,x=3D3)),
+         expand.split=3DTRUE)

Error: block
          Df =
 Sum Sq Mean Sq F value Pr(>F)
Residuals  1 0.57849 0.57849            =
   =


Error: block:a
          Df Sum Sq Mean Sq F value Pr(>F)
a         =
 2 2.0603  1.0301  0.4883 0.6719
  a: t     1 1.4106  1.4106  0.6686 0.=
4994
  a: u     1 0.6497  0.6497  0.3079 0.6347
Residuals  2 4.2194  2=
.1097               =


Error: Within
           Df  Sum Sq Mean Sq F value Pr(>F)
b        =
   3  0.8392  0.2797  0.3034 0.8227
  b: v      1  0.2644  0.2644  0.28=
68 0.5959
  b: w      1  0.0013  0.0013  0.0014 0.9703
  b: x      1  =
0.5734  0.5734  0.6219 0.4360
a:b         6  2.3002  0.3834  0.4158 0.8=
632
  a:b: t.v  1                               =

  a:b: u.v  1                               =

  a:b: t.w  1                               =

  a:b: u.w  1                               =

  a:b: t.x  1                               =

  a:b: u.x  1                               =

Residuals  33 30.4279  0.9221               =

summary(tmp3.aov,

+         split=3Dlist(a=3Dlist(t=3D1,u=3D2)),
+  =
       expand.split=3DTRUE)

Error: block
          Df  Sum Sq Mean S=
q F value Pr(>F)
Residuals  1 0.57849 0.57849               =


Error: block:a
          Df Sum Sq Mean Sq F value Pr(>F)
a         =
 2 2.0603  1.0301  0.4883 0.6719
  a: t     1 1.4106  1.4106  0.6686 0.=
4994
  a: u     1 0.6497  0.6497  0.3079 0.6347
Residuals  2 4.2194  2=
.1097               =


Error: Within
          Df  Sum Sq Mean Sq F value Pr(>F)
b         =
 3  0.8392  0.2797  0.3034 0.8227
a:b        6  2.3002  0.3834  0.4158 =
0.8632
  a:b: t   0  0.0000                       =

  a:b: u   0  0.0000                       =

Residuals 33 30.4279  0.9221               =

=

version

_                           =

platform       i386-pc-mingw32             =

arch           i386                        =

os             mingw32                     =

system         i386, mingw32               =

status                                     =

major          2                           =

minor          8.1                         =

year           2008                        =

month          12                          =

day            22                          =

svn rev        47281                       =

language       R                           =

version.string R version 2.8.1 (2008-12-22)

=

-------62a8e378fd5c9332aae960888fd28459
Content-Type: text/plain;
	name="split.st"
Content-Disposition: inline;
	filename="split.st"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable

tmp <- data.frame(y=3Drnorm(48),

+                   a=3Drep(letters[=
1:3], 16),
+                   b=3Drep(rep(LETTERS[1:4], each=3D3),4),
+                   block=3Drep(LETTERS[5:6], each=3D24)
+             =
      )

=

tmp.aov <- aov(y ~ a*b, data=3Dtmp)
summary(tmp.aov,

+         spl=
it=3Dlist(a=3Dlist(t=3D1,u=3D2), b=3Dlist(v=3D1,w=3D2,x=3D3)),
+       =
  expand.split=3DTRUE)
           Df Sum of Sq  Mean Sq  F Value     Pr=
(F) =

         a  2   0.36016 0.180078 0.141799 0.8682780
      a: t  1   0.0=
3839 0.038393 0.030232 0.8629384
      a: u  1   0.32176 0.321762 0.253=
366 0.6177813
         b  3   4.96430 1.654765 1.303014 0.2883921
    =
  b: v  1   4.84859 4.848586 3.817929 0.0585102
      b: w  1   0.10289=
 0.102887 0.081017 0.7775555
      b: x  1   0.01282 0.012823 0.010097 =
0.9205175
       a:b  6   3.78177 0.630295 0.496314 0.8068076
  a:b: t=
.v  1   0.08038 0.080378 0.063292 0.8027964
  a:b: u.v  1   0.68080 0.6=
80800 0.536083 0.4688007
  a:b: t.w  1   2.29276 2.292763 1.805394 0.18=
74701
  a:b: u.w  1   0.47283 0.472829 0.372321 0.5455749
  a:b: t.x  =
1   0.10382 0.103815 0.081747 0.7765822
  a:b: u.x  1   0.15119 0.15118=
5 0.119048 0.7320772
 Residuals 36  45.71826 1.269952                  =
 =

=

tmp2.aov <- aov(y ~ Error(block) + a*b, data=3Dtmp)
summary(tmp2.ao=

v,
+         split=3Dlist(a=3Dlist(t=3D1,u=3D2), b=3Dlist(v=3D1,w=3D2,x=
=3D3)),
+         expand.split=3DTRUE)
Error: block =

          Df  Sum of Sq    Mean Sq F Value Pr(F) =

Residuals  1 0.01256877 0.01256877              =


Error: Within =

           Df Sum of Sq  Mean Sq  F Value     Pr(F) =

         a  2   0.36016 0.180078 0.137898 0.8716586
      a: t  1   0.0=
3839 0.038393 0.029401 0.8648450
      a: u  1   0.32176 0.321762 0.246=
395 0.6227280
         b  3   4.96430 1.654765 1.267168 0.3006705
    =
  b: v  1   4.84859 4.848586 3.712896 0.0621432
      b: w  1   0.10289=
 0.102887 0.078788 0.7805996
      b: x  1   0.01282 0.012823 0.009819 =
0.9216304
       a:b  6   3.78177 0.630295 0.482660 0.8166555
  a:b: t=
.v  1   0.08038 0.080378 0.061551 0.8055105
  a:b: u.v  1   0.68080 0.6=
80800 0.521335 0.4750693
  a:b: t.w  1   2.29276 2.292763 1.755727 0.19=
37442
  a:b: u.w  1   0.47283 0.472829 0.362078 0.5512326
  a:b: t.x  =
1   0.10382 0.103815 0.079498 0.7796389
  a:b: u.x  1   0.15119 0.15118=
5 0.115773 0.7356989
 Residuals 35  45.70569 1.305877                  =
 =

summary(tmp2.aov,

+         split=3Dlist(a=3Dlist(t=3D1,u=3D2)),
+=
         expand.split=3DTRUE)
Error: block =

          Df  Sum of Sq    Mean Sq F Value Pr(F) =

Residuals  1 0.01256877 0.01256877              =


Error: Within =

          Df Sum of Sq  Mean Sq  F Value     Pr(F) =

        a  2   0.36016 0.180078 0.137898 0.8716586
     a: t  1   0.038=
39 0.038393 0.029401 0.8648450
     a: u  1   0.32176 0.321762 0.246395=
 0.6227280
        b  3   4.96430 1.654765 1.267168 0.3006705
      a:=
b  6   3.78177 0.630295 0.482660 0.8166555
   a:b: t  3   2.47696 0.825=
652 0.632259 0.5991524
   a:b: u  3   1.30481 0.434938 0.333062 0.80147=
81
Residuals 35  45.70569 1.305877                   =

=

tmp3.aov <- aov(y ~ Error(block/a) + a*b, data=3Dtmp)
summary(tmp3.=

aov,
+         split=3Dlist(a=3Dlist(t=3D1,u=3D2), b=3Dlist(v=3D1,w=3D2=
,x=3D3)),
+         expand.split=3DTRUE)
Error: block =

          Df  Sum of Sq    Mean Sq F Value Pr(F) =

Residuals  1 0.01256877 0.01256877              =


Error: a %in% block =

          Df Sum of Sq  Mean Sq   F Value     Pr(F) =

        a  2  0.360156 0.180078 0.0884982 0.9186970
     a: t  1  0.038=
393 0.038393 0.0188683 0.9033255
     a: u  1  0.321762 0.321762 0.1581=
281 0.7293139
Residuals  2  4.069638 2.034819                    =


Error: Within =

           Df Sum of Sq  Mean Sq  F Value     Pr(F) =

         b  3   4.96430 1.654765 1.311538 0.2871289
      b: v  1   4.8=
4859 4.848586 3.842903 0.0584446
      b: w  1   0.10289 0.102887 0.081=
546 0.7769973
      b: x  1   0.01282 0.012823 0.010163 0.9203096
    =
   a:b  6   3.78177 0.630295 0.499561 0.8040295
  a:b: t.v  1   0.08038=
 0.080378 0.063706 0.8022963
  a:b: u.v  1   0.68080 0.680800 0.539590 =
0.4677908
  a:b: t.w  1   2.29276 2.292763 1.817204 0.1868277
  a:b: u=
.w  1   0.47283 0.472829 0.374756 0.5446185
  a:b: t.x  1   0.10382 0.1=
03815 0.082282 0.7760218
  a:b: u.x  1   0.15119 0.151185 0.119827 0.73=
14199
 Residuals 33  41.63605 1.261699                   =

summary(tmp3.aov,

+         split=3Dlist(a=3Dlist(t=3D1,u=3D2)),
+=
         expand.split=3DTRUE)
Error: block =

          Df  Sum of Sq    Mean Sq F Value Pr(F) =

Residuals  1 0.01256877 0.01256877              =


Error: a %in% block =

          Df Sum of Sq  Mean Sq   F Value     Pr(F) =

        a  2  0.360156 0.180078 0.0884982 0.9186970
     a: t  1  0.038=
393 0.038393 0.0188683 0.9033255
     a: u  1  0.321762 0.321762 0.1581=
281 0.7293139
Residuals  2  4.069638 2.034819                    =


Error: Within =

          Df Sum of Sq  Mean Sq  F Value     Pr(F) =

        b  3   4.96430 1.654765 1.311538 0.2871289
      a:b  6   3.781=
77 0.630295 0.499561 0.8040295
   a:b: t  3   2.47696 0.825652 0.654397=
 0.5859203
   a:b: u  3   1.30481 0.434938 0.344724 0.7931477
Residual=
s 33  41.63605 1.261699                   =

version

TIBCO Spotfire S+ Version 8.1.1 for Microsoft Windows : 200=
8 =

=

-------62a8e378fd5c9332aae960888fd28459--