Why no BIC.default function?

I'm using R 2.0.1.

I looked in the email archives but didn't see anything on this topic.

I've noticed a surprising (to me) difference between AIC and BIC:

methods("AIC")

[1] AIC.default* AIC.logLik*

methods("BIC")

[1] BIC.gls*    BIC.lm*     BIC.lme*    BIC.lmList* BIC.logLik* BIC.nls*

The BIC.gls BIC.lm BIC.lme BIC.lmList and BIC.nls functions appear to have
exactly the same definition.  (I didn't check with 'diff' though.)

Would it make sense to treat BIC similarly to AIC and have just
BIC.default and BIC.logLik?

I'm using R 2.0.1.

I looked in the email archives but didn't see anything on this topic.

I've noticed a surprising (to me) difference between AIC and BIC:

methods("AIC")

[1] AIC.default* AIC.logLik*

methods("BIC")

[1] BIC.gls*    BIC.lm*     BIC.lme*    BIC.lmList* BIC.logLik* BIC.nls*

The BIC.gls BIC.lm BIC.lme BIC.lmList and BIC.nls functions appear to have
exactly the same definition.  (I didn't check with 'diff' though.)

Would it make sense to treat BIC similarly to AIC and have just
BIC.default and BIC.logLik?

R does not have a BIC S3 generic function: it is in package nlme!
(There is one for S4 classes in package stats4.)

I'm using R 2.0.1.

I looked in the email archives but didn't see anything on this topic.

I've noticed a surprising (to me) difference between AIC and BIC:

methods("AIC")

[1] AIC.default* AIC.logLik*

methods("BIC")

[1] BIC.gls*    BIC.lm*     BIC.lme*    BIC.lmList* BIC.logLik* BIC.nls*

The BIC.gls BIC.lm BIC.lme BIC.lmList and BIC.nls functions appear to
have
exactly the same definition.  (I didn't check with 'diff' though.)

Would it make sense to treat BIC similarly to AIC and have just
BIC.default and BIC.logLik?

--
Brian D. Ripley,                  ripley@stats.ox.ac.uk
Professor of Applied Statistics,  http://www.stats.ox.ac.uk/~ripley/
University of Oxford,             Tel:  +44 1865 272861 (self)
1 South Parks Road,                     +44 1865 272866 (PA)
Oxford OX1 3TG, UK                Fax:  +44 1865 272595