Old g++ in Rtools

I???m working on a Mac so ymmv, but I???ve been running benchmarks of
vanilla R from cran vs. recompiles with different versions of gcc and
R, and I see a speedup of 20-30% vs the cran binary after recompiling
with gnu 4.9. ??Its quite distinct. ??

Each jump in gcc revision (4.7-4.8, 4.8-4.9) seems to improve benchmark
performance by around 10% over the previous generation. ??

So there may be advantages to recompiling yourself.

On the other hand, there may be potential issues compiling some
packages. ??Some of the benchmarking I???ve been doing is 3.1.1 vs. pqR
(distinctly faster than 3.1.1, even without ???helper threads???),
which is based on R 2.15.0, which in turn forces you to use older
versions of some packages, some of which have language-compatibility
issues with recent compilers. ??The version of Rcpp that accepts R
2.15.0, for example, won???t compile against gcc 4.9. ??You may find
that the current versions of other packages have similar issues with
recent gnu compilers, I can???t say. ??

I???m surprised, frankly, that there isn???t more discussion of this,
considering the size of the data and complexity of the problems people
are feeding into R, and the possibility of essentially ???free???
performance boosts.

--??
Amos Elberg
Sent with Airmail

From:??Rguy <rguy at 123mail.org>
Reply:??Rguy <rguy at 123mail.org>>
Date:??August 6, 2014 at 2:47:47 AM
To:??r-help at r-project.org <r-help at r-project.org>>
Subject:?? [R] Old g++ in Rtools  

I recently downloaded Rtools. I see the g++ version is  
gcc version 4.6.3 20111208 (prerelease) (GCC)  

I also recently downloaded MinGW. Its version of g++ is  
gcc version 4.8.1 (GCC)  

I believe that later versions of g++ provide better support for C++11. 

Why does Rtools provide a version considerably older than the latest?  
Any plans to update the version?  
Is it bad practice to compile with a later version when interfacing
with R?  

[[alternative HTML version deleted]]  

I recently downloaded Rtools. I see the g++ version is
gcc version 4.6.3 20111208 (prerelease) (GCC)

I also recently downloaded MinGW. Its version of g++ is
gcc version 4.8.1 (GCC)

I believe that later versions of g++ provide better support for C++11.
Why does Rtools provide a version considerably older than the latest?
Any plans to update the version?
Is it bad practice to compile with a later version when interfacing with R?