[External] Amazing AI

Next year one of my R programming assigments will read like this:

"Here is some R code written by a multi-million dollar AI system to
compute [something]. It doesn't work. Fix the bugs, then ask the AI to
write a letter to its creators apologising for how rubbish it is at
coding. Collect one million dollars."

On Sun, Dec 18, 2022 at 7:01 PM Boris Steipe <boris.steipe at utoronto.ca> wrote:

This email originated outside the University. Check before clicking links or attachments.

Technically not a help question. But crucial to be aware of, especially for those of us in academia, or otherwise teaching R. I am not aware of a suitable alternate forum. If this does not interest you, please simply ignore - I already know that this may be somewhat OT.

Thanks.
------------------------------------------------------

You very likely have heard of ChatGPT, the conversation interface on top of the GPT-3 large language model and that it can generate code. I thought it doesn't do R - I was wrong. Here is a little experiment:

MY PROMPT:
==========
Please write me some R code that will read a tsv file, remove all rows that have duplicates in the column "names", and store the median values of the remaining rows in a variable called "Medians". Of course, that calculation should only be done with columns that are numeric. Print the last variable in order from largest to smallest.


AI RESPONSE:
============

Here is some R code that should accomplish what you've described:

(Note: the code is formatted in a little terminal window, complete with a button to "copy code" at the top.)

----
# Read the tsv file
data <- read.table("file.tsv", header = TRUE, sep = "\t")

# Remove rows with duplicates in the "names" column
data <- data[!duplicated(data$names), ]

# Select only the numeric columns
num_columns <- sapply(data, is.numeric)
numeric_data <- data[, num_columns]

# Calculate the medians for each column
Medians <- apply(numeric_data, 1, median)

# Sort Medians in descending order
Medians <- sort(Medians, decreasing = TRUE)

# Print Medians
print(Medians)
----

This code assumes that the tsv file is called "file.tsv" and is stored in the current working directory. It also assumes that the first row of the file contains the column names.



MY PROMPT:
==========
Can you provide me with a bit of sample data that I can use to test this code?

AI RESPONSE:
============
Certainly! Here is some sample data that you can use to test the code I provided:

----
name    age     height  weight
Alice   23      5.6     120
Bob     32      6.2     180
Charlie 29      5.9     160
Alice   23      5.6     120
David   25      5.8     140
Eve     27      5.5     110
----

You can save this data as a tsv file and use it to test the code.


------------------------------------------------------

Notes:
1) The code, as written does not work with the test data. The reason is that the test data specifies a column "name", but the code assumes "names" (which I specified in the instructions). Once this is fixed in the test data, the code executes.

2) The instructions are not accurately translated: I had asked for row means. But changing the margin in the apply() statement from 2 to 1 does the correct thing.

3) Note that the test data contains both numeric and non-numeric columns. Also, the name "Alice" is duplicated in the test data, which is subtle, and the right thing to do.


------------------------------------------------------

A similar experiment, run on the beta-site of OpenAI's Codex code-completion tool gives the following code (complete with the comments.):

----
# Read in the data
data <- read.table("mydata.tsv", sep = "\t", header = TRUE)

# Remove all rows that have duplicates in the column "names"
unique_names <- unique(data$names)
data_unique <- data[data$names %in% unique_names,]

# Calculate medians
Medians <- sapply(data_unique[, sapply(data_unique, is.numeric)], median, na.rm = TRUE)

# Print last variable in order form largest to smallest
rev(sort(Medians[length(Medians)]))
----

Note that the strategy is quite different (e.g using %in%, not duplicated() ), the interpretation of "last variable" is technically correct but not what I had in mind (ChatGPT got that right though).


Changing my prompts slightly resulted it going for a dplyr solution instead, complete with %>% idioms etc ... again, syntactically correct but not giving me the fully correct results.

------------------------------------------------------

Bottom line: The AI's ability to translate natural language instructions into code is astounding. Errors the AI makes are subtle and probably not easy to fix if you don't already know what you are doing. But the way that this can be "confidently incorrect" and plausible makes it nearly impossible to detect unless you actually run the code (you may have noticed that when you read the code).

Will our students use it? Absolutely.

Will they successfully cheat with it? That depends on the assignment. We probably need to _encourage_ them to use it rather than sanction - but require them to attribute the AI, document prompts, and identify their own, additional contributions.

Will it help them learn? When you are aware of the issues, it may be quite useful. It may be especially useful to teach them to specify their code carefully and completely, and to ask questions in the right way. Test cases are crucial.

How will it affect what we do as instructors? I don't know. Really.

And the future? I am not pleased to extrapolate to a job market in which they compete with knowledge workers who work 24/7 without benefits, vacation pay, or even a salary. They'll need to rethink the value of their investment in an academic education. We'll need to rethink what we do to provide value above and beyond what AI's can do. (Nb. all of the arguments I hear about why humans will always be better etc. are easily debunked, but that's even more OT :-)

--------------------------------------------------------

If you have thoughts to share how your institution is thinking about academic integrity in this situation, or creative ideas how to integrate this into teaching, I'd love to hear from you.


All the best!
Boris


--
Boris Steipe MD, PhD
University of Toronto