Skip to content
Prev 12021 / 12125 Next

[R-pkg-devel] CRAN submissions down?

For what it is worth in my case as far as I can tell the behaviors of both devtools::submit_cran and the cran machine were quote reasonable,  even if it caused me a little pain.  The block Uwe describes sounds like fail2ban or the like,  and given the junk we see hitting our services  it is a reasonable thing to run.  I had the day wrong when I thought cran was back up.  devtools on submission said ti couldn?t connect,  It is not unreasonable as a submitter, thinking the machine was back up,  to wait a bit,  and  try again,  and maybe do so a few times throughout the day.  That is indeed what I did.  Then to be sure it wasn?t a devtools problem I went to the web page  and that is when it seemed to block me. 

So my point is everything to my mind behaved reasonably.  The only thing I could suggest,  and I have no idea of how much work this would entail, and I am not looking to make work for people,  is perhaps a banner on the webpage when the service is down,  and if possible have the server return to programs  like devtools an error that the service is down.

I can?t speak for why others were blocked,  but as I said this all seems reasonable.

Thanks,

-Roy