Skip to content

[R-pkg-devel] advice on reminders/nags to CRAN maintainers

3 messages · Ben Bolker, Reed A. Cartwright, Alejandro Ruete

Original
Ben Bolker
# 
Wondering about etiquette/if I should start over again with a package 
submission. tl;dr, the package has been 'waiting' since 30 July (I 
responded the same day to the queries that were sent).

   For what it's worth, the 'pretest-waiting-recheck' message below was 
sent from *a* CRAN maintainer, but hitting "reply-all" in my mail client 
only included the "CRAN-submissions at -rproject.org" address. Maybe my 
mail client is misconfigured ? supposed to respond to the sender as well 
as the Reply-To: address? I could poke the individual CM who sent it 
personally, but I'm loath to do that unnecessarily ...


    thoughts?
    Ben Bolker

---

(Some previous history omitted here for brevity; there had been a bit of 
back-and-forth about this package previously.)

   07/30: Submitted version 1.1.2.2 of the glmmTMB package.  Got a 
"pretest-waiting-recheck" message asking us to confirm that we had 
addressed issues; I responded the same day.

   08/04, 08/06: Tried to confirm that the message was received (maybe I 
was too pushy?) -- no answer that I have seen.

   The CRAN queue in general seems to be moving OK 
(foghorn::cran_incoming(), 'archive' folder filtered out, sorted by 
time: 57 total, 45 from today or yesterday).

    package      version    cran_folder time
    <chr>        <pckg_vrs> <chr>       <dttm>
  1 BIRDS        0.2.1      pending     2021-07-21 17:01:00
  2 glmmTMB      1.1.2.2    waiting     2021-07-30 20:29:00
  3 PEcAn.logger 1.8.0      waiting     2021-08-05 18:58:00
  4 IPDFileCheck 0.7.4      waiting     2021-08-06 11:15:00
  5 R6           2.5.1      waiting     2021-08-06 22:27:00
  6 ibdreg       0.3.3      pending     2021-08-06 23:41:00
  7 mark         0.2.0      waiting     2021-08-08 23:25:00
  8 DataGraph    1.2.3      pending     2021-08-09 03:11:00
  9 tibble       3.1.4      waiting     2021-08-09 05:46:00
1 day later
Reed A. Cartwright
# 
I'm also waiting several weeks for an update to be approved or sent back to
me.

In the meantime, the package has been archived by CRAN because the update
--- which fixes issues identified by CRAN --- hasn't been approved yet.
On Wed, Aug 11, 2021 at 10:44 AM Ben Bolker <bbolker at gmail.com> wrote:

            

      
      
      
    

        

      
      
    

        

  
  


  


      

    

    

      
      

        


  

        

      Alejandro Ruete
    

    

      
      #
    

  


  

      
Same here. I did the mistake to reply directly and now I am blacklisted
from one of the CM email list.

Alejandro




Alejandro Ruete
about.me/alejandro.ruete
  <http://about.me/alejandro.ruete>


On Fri, 13 Aug 2021 at 00:42, Reed A. Cartwright <racartwright at gmail.com>
wrote: