Skip to content
Prev 329 / 7420 Next

Are likelihood approaches frequentist?

Ben Bolker wrote:
Hi Ben,
I just posted a reference to his general ideas on model selection to the 
list.
I agree with Paulo's answer. If you want a cutoff value from the normed 
likelihood to make an interval of precision for one parameter, then a 
socialized reference cutoff value will have to be agreed, like the 
p-value=0.05 of sampling-distribution inference. But that is not 
absolutely necessary I believe. If you refrain from making intervals, 
then you can report your parameter estimate and its precision by means 
of the curvature of the likelihood around the maximum w.r.t. to that 
parameter (the formation concept of Edwards, akin to the estimation 
variance but without the asymptotics, fully conditional on the observed 
sample), and that's it.
If you want to make an interval, then I prefer Royall's proposal of a 
canonical experiment. I think it appeals well to intuition.
Regards
Rub?n