Skip to content
Prev 576 / 7420 Next

2 questions about NMDS in vegan

Manuel & readers,

I didn't comment on the use of stepacross with Euclidean distances  
earlier, but I do it now: I don't think it makes sense. This is a user  
choice, and technically it now works in the R-Forge version of vegan,  
but I do think that no user should do this (but what am I to stop  
them?). The problem is that the distances among points with nothing in  
common are not necessarily longest Euclidean distances. You may have  
very short Euclidean distances between two sites with no shared  
species if the total abundances in these two sites are low. So the  
stepacross finds the distances across low abundance sites instead of  
really intermediate sites. I do think that you should use stepacross  
only with the usual closed indices with upper limit = 1. If you want  
to use them with open indices (no upper limit, variable values for  
pairs with nothing in common), you should be prepared to research the  
adequacy of your choice.

Setting noshare=0 will turn off automatic stepacross in metaMDS. I  
recommend this be used with Euclidean, Manhattan and other open  
distances, although this is not enforced: the choice is yours.

Cheers, Jari Oksanen