GTK+ support (or rather lack thereof)

For what it's worth, Homebrew and macports both have scripts for
installing GTK+ from sources, so presumedly those could be cribbed
into a standalone shell script for a build if desired:

https://github.com/Homebrew/homebrew-core/blob/master/Formula/gtk+.rb
https://github.com/macports/macports-ports/blob/master/gnome/gtk2/Portfile

Would that be worth exploring? I'd be willing to try and put something
together if so.

Also -- is the intention to stick with the latest patch release of the
GTK+ 2.x series, or try to upgrade to GTK+ 3.x? (I suspect that
GTK+-using packages would likely need to adapt to changes in GTK+ 3.x)

Kevin

On Thu, Apr 2, 2020 at 6:03 PM Simon Urbanek
<simon.urbanek at r-project.org> wrote:

We have a fairly complete coverage of packages for R 4.0.0, but one

exception is GTK+ (and thus RGtk2 and its dependencies). It seems that GTK+
has been abandoned several years ago, the documented macOS build doesn't
work and there are no released binaries. To make things worse, Gnome has
been switching from autoconf to custom build systems that are also broken
(quite amazing - the build fails with an error in the build system's
headers including Python headers...), so the path of building our own
release from scratch is also not realistic anymore (we used to build GTK+
for X11 when it was still possible).

Hence this is a call to the R community to see if anyone actually cares.

And if so, if there is any known source or path to macOS binaries (script
to build it is fine, too). Unlike regular rules, we would allow dynamic
linking as we have granted that exception to GTK+ before, but it has to be
compatible with the native system. As a last resort, we could also re-use
out GTK+ 2.24.17 binaries from Snow Leopard, but those are considerably
old, so I'd prefer not to do that. Comments are welcome.

Thanks,
Simon