[R-meta] Can we call moderators in subgroup analysis predictors?

I think the reviewer uses the term "meta-analysis" exclusively when
pooling a bunch of effects into a single weighted average. So, to him/her,
it does not make sense to say that there are
predictors/moderators/covariates (whatever you want to call them) in a
meta-analysis. If there are predictors in the model, then the reviewer
wants this to be called "meta-regression" and not "meta-analysis with
predictors". I don't think the comment has anything to do with whether you
use the term predictor or moderator.

Best,
Wolfgang

-----Original Message-----
From: R-sig-meta-analysis [mailto:

r-sig-meta-analysis-bounces at r-project.org]

On Behalf Of Simon Harmel
Sent: Sunday, 20 December, 2020 0:39
To: Michael Dewey
Cc: R meta
Subject: Re: [R-meta] Can we call moderators in subgroup analysis
predictors?

Thank you Michael. I had the same reaction. So, this was from a reviewer
who mentioned:

"You say moderators will eventually serve as predictors in a

meta-analysis,

are you referring to meta-regression here? Moderators are not used as
predictors in a classic meta-analysis which simply pools all the effects
into a weighted effect size."

My response was:

". . . In both cases, categorical moderators/predictors act as on-and-off
switches. I always prefer the meta-regression as it reveals the partial
effect of one moderator controlling for other moderators. But again, in my
context it is fine to generally use the term predictor. I think some may
even find the term moderator confusing because in general it may denote
some kind of interactional effect".

Just wanted to make sure I'm not too far off.

Thanks,
Simon

On Sat, Dec 19, 2020 at 4:32 AM Michael Dewey <lists at dewey.myzen.co.uk>
wrote:

Dear Simon

My immediate thought is, "Yes, why not?" but do you have some deep doubt
you want to share with us?

Michael

On 18/12/2020 22:51, Simon Harmel wrote:

For clarification, I'm only concerned with categorical moderators.

Thanks again,
Simon

On Fri, Dec 18, 2020 at 3:33 PM Simon Harmel <sim.harmel at gmail.com>

wrote:

Hello All,

A quick question. In classic meta-analysis, moderators help to form

groups

of studies and conduct meta analysis separately in each group.

In meta-regression, moderators are directly predictors of effect size

in a

regression analysis.

But, can we still call moderators in classic meta-analysis predictors

of

effect size?

Thank you,
Simon