Skip to content
Prev 7366 / 20628 Next

Using Observations as Random Effect in GLMM?

John Maindonald <john.maindonald at ...> writes:
Recent versions of the glmmADMB package offer two flavors of negative
binomial model, either with variance = mu*(1+mu/k) (the classic
'quadratic' (almost) parameterization, which Hardin and Hilbe call
NB2) or with variance = phi*mu (which Hardin and Hilbe call
NB1; I believe this is what you are calling "quasi-Poisson" above).
The variance-mean relationship of NB2 and of the lognormal-Poisson
model are the same, although the details do differ ...
I haven't tried it yet, but my response to the original poster
would have been to try a well-behaved simulation and see whether
the same phenomenon occurred ...