Comparing the AICs roughly corresponds to a LR-test with a level of about .16 (Greven S, Kneib T(2009), http://www.bepress.com/jhubiostat/paper202/), and the standard likelihood ratio tests or F-tests will give you a (very) conservative test (as you can see from Ben Bolker's GLMM -Wiki). Package RLRsim provides an exact restricted likelihood ratio test for testing single random effects in linear mixed models. It only works if the random effect you're testing is uncorrelated with the remaining random effects in the model, though. HTH, Fabian
test significance of single random effect
1 message · Fabian Scheipl