Today I came across the announcement of the tutorial at the UseR! Conference in Dortmund "Introduction to Robust Statistics with R" and was surprised to see that it will "... use R functions mainly from packages 'MASS' and ..." I wonder what does 'MASS' still has that 'robustbase' & cie do not have? Best regards, Valentin
[RsR] Tutorial: Introduction to Robust Statistics with R
3 messages · Valentin Todorov, Martin Maechler
"ValenT" == Valentin Todorov <valentin.todorov at chello.at>
on Fri, 6 Jun 2008 23:49:49 +0200 writes:
ValenT> Today I came across the announcement of the tutorial at the UseR! Conference
ValenT> in Dortmund "Introduction to Robust Statistics with R" and was surprised to
ValenT> see that it will "... use R functions mainly from packages 'MASS' and ..."
didn't you guess I was the culprit ? :-)
I think I mainly mentioned MASS because it's been a standard R
package for a long time.
ValenT> I wonder what does 'MASS' still has that 'robustbase' & cie do not have?
Probably not much, but
simple M-estimate for regression with flexible choice of
psi/rho function is something not available as "high-level"
in robustbase::lmrob() nor robust::lmRob() I think.
E.g. if you have only categorical predictors, such "simple" M estimates
may make much sense, no?
Regards,
Martin
Hey Martin, why do you read/write mails instead of watching the EM matches
(sorry)?! I do not care much about soccer too but just opened a bottle of
Portuguese wine to celebrate and would like to use the opportunity to
congratulate our Portuguese robastniks.
ValenT>Today I came across the announcement of the tutorial at the UseR!
Conference
ValenT>in Dortmund "Introduction to Robust Statistics with R" and was
surprised to
ValenT> see that it will "... use R functions mainly from packages
'MASS' and ..."
didn't you guess I was the culprit? :-)
Of course I did, therefore I allowed myself to pull your leg.
I think I mainly mentioned MASS because it's been a standard R package for a long time.
Then you should mention also MINVOL, ROBETH, COVINTER, PROGRESS which were around for quite a long time so far and are in all caps too. But seriously speaking, 'MASS' stroke my eyes and I am sure that this will be what a newcomer will take home (the advantage of all caps you know, we should rather have chosen ROBUSTBASE). Best regards, Valentin